Council and democracy
Home > Council and Democracy > Agenda and minutes
Venue: Council Chamber, The Guildhall, Market Square, Cambridge, CB2 3QJ [access the building via Peashill entrance]. View directions
Contact: Toni Birkin Committee Manager
No. | Item | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Apologies Minutes: Apologies were received from Councillor Holt. Councillor Page-Croft was present as alternative. |
||||||||||
Declarations of Interest Members are asked to declare at this stage any interests, which they may have in any of the following items on the agenda. If any member is unsure whether or not they should declare an interest on a particular matter, they are requested to seek advice from the Monitoring Officer before the meeting. Minutes:
|
||||||||||
Minutes to follow. Minutes: The minutes of the meeting of the 26th April 2017 were agreed and signed as a correct record. |
||||||||||
17/0473/FUL - University Sports and Athletic Track, Wilberforce Road PDF 234 KB
Minutes: The Committee received an application for
full planning permission. The application sought approval for the construction of two artificial
grass pitches (AGPs), installation of floodlighting to both pitches,
replacement fencing to existing pitch, extension of balcony on western
elevation of the pavilion, insertion of two sets of doors on north elevation of
pavilion, replacement of pitched roof with flat roof on scorer's hut,
construction of an electrical substation, car and cycle parking and associated
landscaping and drainage works. The
Committee noted the amendment sheet. An
error regarding the nature of Cambridge Past, Present and Future’s
representation was noted. The Committee received a representation in objection to the application
from a nearby resident. The representation covered the following issues:
i.
Spoke on behalf of herself, and other residents the
development would impact on.
ii.
Residents did not object to the extension of sports
provision. However, they objected to the increased lighting.
iii.
Site had a long planning history and previous
lighting applications had been rejected. iv.
Welcomed the comments regarding the impact on Coton footpath.
v.
From October to March residents would experience no
natural dusk. vi.
The provision of additional pitches should mean
that additional floodlight hours are not needed. vii.
Aspect of open space would be lost. viii.
Horizon views were important. Karen Pearce, Assistant Director of Sport at the University of Cambridge
and Tim Ireland of Cambridge City Hockey Club, addressed the Committee in
support of the application. Councillor
Nethsingha proposed an amendment to condition 16 of the Officer’s
recommendation that the existing permitted lighting hours be retained. This amendment was lost
by 3 votes to 2. The Committee: Resolved
(by 5 votes to 2) to grant the application for planning permission in accordance with the
officer recommendation, for the reasons set out in the officer report, and subject
to the conditions recommended by the officers and subject to the amendments
above. Conditions 17 and 19 are deleted, and renumber 18 and 20-26 accordingly) |
||||||||||
16/1864/FUL - St Edmunds College, Mount Pleasant PDF 205 KB Minutes: The Committee received an application for
full planning permission. The application
sought approval for the erection of extensions to Norfolk Building for common
room, 16 student rooms, college offices and research space, cafe and kitchens;
erection of 6 family
accommodation units; landscaping and cycle parking following demolition of
maisonettes. The Committee
noted the amendment sheet. Matthew Bullock, Master of St Edmunds College, addressed the Committee
in support of the application. The Committee: Unanimously
resolved to grant the application for planning permission in accordance with the
officer recommendation, for the reasons set out in the officer report, and
subject to the conditions recommended by the officers and subject to
condition 18 being reworded as follows: “No
new windows shall be constructed in the existing building, nor existing windows
altered until drawings at a scale of 1:50 of details of new or altered sills,
lintels, jambs, transoms, and mullions have been submitted to and approved in
writing by the local planning authority. The development shall be carried out
in accordance with the approved details. Reason:
To avoid harm to the special interest of the Conservation Area. (Cambridge
Local Plan 2006, policy 4/11)” |
||||||||||
16/2126/FUL - 21-23 Milton Road PDF 63 KB Minutes: The Committee received an application for
full planning permission. The application sought approval for the installation of a 20 sq metres extension to flat 6 and alterations to the internal
layout of flat 5 - minor material amendment to application 15/1529/FUL for the
erection of 10 dwellings. The
Committee noted pre-committee amendments to the recommendation set out on the
amendment sheet. The Committee: Unanimously resolved to grant the application for planning
permission in accordance with the officer recommendation, for the reasons set
out in the officer report, and subject to the conditions recommended by the
officers. |
||||||||||
17/0101/FUL - 150 Catharine Street PDF 99 KB Minutes: The Committee received an application for full
planning permission. The application sought approval for erection
of five self-contained studios and associated works. The Committee: Resolved (by 5 votes to 2) to grant the
application for planning permission in accordance with the officer
recommendation, for the reasons set out in the officer report, and subject to
the conditions recommended by the officers. |
||||||||||
16/2214/FUL - 1 Moyne Close PDF 67 KB Minutes: The Committee received an application for
full planning permission. The application sought approval for a two
storey side and rear extension and the conversion of the extended property to 2
x two bed flats. The Committee received a representation in objection
to the application from a resident of Ashvale. The representation covered the following
concerns: i.
The application would exacerbate existing
parking and access issues, particularly as a local school was located nearby. ii.
Impact of the application on
residents’ amenities: a.
Noise. b.
Loss of light. The Committee: Unanimously resolved to grant the application for planning
permission in accordance with the officer recommendation, for the reasons set
out in the officer report, and subject to the conditions recommended by the
officers. |
||||||||||
16/1901/FUL - 147 Coldhams Lane PDF 71 KB Minutes: The Committee received an application for
change of use. The application sought approval for property
to become a seven person house in multiple occupation (sui generis) following
proposed rear single storey annexe and single-storey rear extension (approved
under reference 16/0613/FUL). The Planning Officer updated his report by
recommending an additional condition the the annexe,
shall be used in association with the HMO accommodation at No.147 Coldhams Lane only. Mrs Oliver (Applicant) addressed the
Committee in support of the application. The Committee: Unanimously resolved to grant the application for change
of use in
accordance with the officer recommendation, for the reasons set out in the
officer report, and subject to the conditions recommended by the officers plus
additional condition: “The annexe, hereby permitted, shall be used in association with the HMO accommodation at No.147 Coldhams Lane only and shall not be occupied as a separate independent residential unit. Reason – Use as an independent dwelling is likely to give rise to an unsatisfactory level of privacy and residential amenity for occupiers of both the HMO and dwelling. This application has been assessed on the basis that the annexe would be used in conjunction with the HMO so the merits of a separate dwelling have not been considered (Cambridge Local Plan 2006, Policies 3/7, 4/13 and 5/7).” |
||||||||||
17/0251/FUL - 293 Campkin Road PDF 74 KB Minutes: The Committee received an application for change
of use. The application
sought approval for change of use of the site from a three-bedroom dwellinghouse to an eight person house in multiple occupation. The Committee: Unanimously resolved to grant the application for change
of use
in accordance with the officer recommendation, for the reasons set out in the
officer report. |
||||||||||
17/0493/FUL - 190-192 Mill Road PDF 59 KB Minutes: The Committee received an application for change of use. The application
sought approval for change of use from Retail (Use Class A1) to Tattoo Parlour
(Sui Generis Use). Mr Haupt (Applicant) addressed the Committee
in support of the application. The Committee: Unanimously resolved to grant the application for change of use
in accordance with the officer recommendation, for the reasons set out in the
officer report, and subject to the conditions recommended by the officers. |
||||||||||
17/0236/LBC - Cambridge Railway Station PDF 41 KB Minutes: The Committee received an application for
listed building consent. The application sought approval for
installation of 6 ‘iVision’ advertising display units
within the station foyer Councillor Robertson (Petersfield Ward Councillor)
addressed the Committee about the application. The representation covered the following
issues: i.
The arches in the station provide
a distinct style of architecture. ii.
The advertising panels would
negatively impact on the station architecture and views of Cambridge from the
station. iii.
Took issue with: a.
Screens/displays being used for
adverts. b.
Size of the screens proposed for
use in a listed building. c.
Proposed location of the 4 screens
near the (listed building) entrance (the 2 near the platform caused no
objections). The Committee: Resolved (by 6 votes to 2) to reject the officer recommendation to approve the application. Resolved (by 6
votes to 1) minded to
refuse the application contrary to the officer recommendation for the following
reason: The proposed advertising display units by virtue of their number, size
and position would have an adverse impact on the significance and special
interest of the Listed station building. In particular
the four advertising display units adjacent to the doors fronting Station
Square would detract from the distinctive arched openings and in so doing would
fail to preserve this particular feature of special architectural
interest. These four advertising display
units would also fail to preserve the setting of the Station which is a
prominent public building within Cambridge.
The application is therefore contrary to Policy 4/10 of the Cambridge
Local Plan 2006 and the public benefit arising from the installation of the
advertising display units does not outweigh the harm to the listed building. |
||||||||||
17/0452/FUL - 7 Celtic House, Hooper Street PDF 60 KB Minutes: The Committee received an application for full
planning permission. The application
sought approval for a first floor extension to create a 1 bed flat above existing
ground floor flat. The City Development Manager read a written statement on behalf of the
Applicant in support of the application. The Committee: Unanimously resolved to grant the application for planning
permission in accordance with the officer recommendation, for the reasons set
out in the officer report, and subject to the conditions recommended by the
officers. |
||||||||||
17/0340/FUL - 8 Green End Road PDF 118 KB Minutes: The Committee received an application for full
planning permission. The application sought approval for the
erection of 5 x one bed dwellings with associated landscaping following the
demolition of the existing bungalow on site. The Committee received a representation in
objection to the application from a representative of Gainsborough Close
Residents Association. The representation covered the following
issues: i.
Objected to the proposed houses
opening onto, and therefore getting access by, a privately owned path. ii.
Queried if the Council would
assume maintenance responsibility for the path if planning approval was given
to the application. iii.
Suggested construction work would
block the path so queried how access would be retained. The Committee: Resolved (by 7 votes to 1) to grant the
application for planning permission in accordance with the officer
recommendation, for the reasons set out in the officer report, and subject to
the conditions recommended by the officers. |
||||||||||
16/2231/S73 - 7A Holyrood Close PDF 60 KB Minutes: The Committee received a Section 73
application. The application sought approval to vary
condition 2 of planning permission 13/1799/FUL dated 06/03/2014 for the
erection of a three bedroom bungalow to allow the relocation of the dwelling. The Planning Officer referred to amended
conditions 6 and 7 set out on the amendment sheet. The Committee: Unanimously resolved to grant the Section 73 application in
accordance with the officer recommendation, for the reasons set out in the
officer report, and subject to the conditions recommended by the officers. Delegated powers were
given so Officers could update the wording of conditions 6 and 7 to incorporate
the latest legislation and to specify the relevant use classes. |
||||||||||
17/0025/FUL - 42 Pretoria Road PDF 61 KB Minutes: The Committee received an application for
retrospective temporary change of use to office (B1A). The Committee: Unanimously resolved to grant the application for retrospective temporary change of use in accordance
with the officer recommendation, for the reasons set out in the officer report,
and subject to the conditions recommended by the officers. |
||||||||||
16/2191/FUL - 5 Ferndale Rise PDF 77 KB
Additional documents: Minutes: Councillor Blencowe withdrew from the meeting for this item and did not participate in the discussion or decision making. Councillor Hipkin left the meeting and Councillor Smart took the Chair. Councillor Holland joined as the alternate. The Committee received an application for full planning permission. The application sought approval for a two storey rear extension and change of use from C4 HMO (6 persons) to No.4 one bedroom flats. The Committee: Resolved (unanimously - by 7 votes to 0) to grant the
application for planning permission in accordance with the officer
recommendation, for the reasons set out in the officer report, and subject to
the conditions recommended by the officers. |
||||||||||
17/0347/FUL - 8 Gerard Close PDF 63 KB Minutes: The Committee received an application for change of use. The application sought approval for change of use from a single dwelling
to a House in Multiple Occupation (HMO) (sui generis) and erection of single and
two storey extensions to the rear. Also the erection of cycle and bin stores
and a 1.5 metre high fence to front. The Committee: Unanimously resolved to grant the application for change of use
in accordance with the officer recommendation, for the reasons set out in the
officer report, and subject to the conditions recommended by the officers. |
||||||||||
TPO 01/2017 and 17/138/TTPO - Lovell Lodge Hotel, Milton Road PDF 109 KB Additional documents: Minutes: The Committee
received an application to confirm, not to confirm, or confirm subject to
modifications the Tree Preservation Order 01/2017 that relates to Lovell Lodge
Hotel. The Committee: Unanimously
resolved to accept the
officer recommendation and grant permission to confirm the TPO that was the
subject of the application. |
||||||||||
TPO 05/2017 - 16 Brunswick Gardens PDF 5 MB Minutes: The Committee
received an application to confirm, not to confirm, or confirm subject
to modifications the Tree Preservation Order 05/2017 that relates to 16 Brunswick
Gardens. The Committee: Unanimously
resolved to accept the
officer recommendation and grant permission to confirm the TPO that was the
subject of the application. |
||||||||||
TPO 03/2017 - Hornbeam House PDF 4 MB Minutes: The Committee
received an application to confirm, not to confirm, or confirm subject to
modifications the Tree Preservation Order 03/2017 that relates to Hornbeam
House. Members were also
asked to decide whether or not to allow the tree works proposed in application
17/198/TTPO. The Committee: Unanimously
resolved to accept the
officer recommendations and grant permission: (i) To confirm the TPO that was the subject of the
application without amendment. (ii) To allow the works detailed in tree work application 17/198/TTPO, subject
to condition. |