Council and democracy
Home > Council and Democracy > Decision details
Decision Maker: Cabinet
Decision status: For Determination
Is Key decision?: Yes
Is subject to call in?: Yes
The
Civic Quarter is the historic heart of Cambridge. For centuries it has been the
place where the city's civic, commercial and cultural life has come together.
The Market Square has hosted trading activity since the Middle Ages, the
Guildhall site has served as a centre of local government for approximately 800
years, and the Corn Exchange – the largest music venue in the East of England -
has been a focal point for entertainment, culture and community life for more
than 150 years. Together these grade 2 listed assets form one of the most
important collections of civic heritage buildings and spaces in the city.
1.1 The Cabinet unanimously
resolved to note:
I. The recommendation of the Director of
Economy and Place, on the balance of all considerations – financial, civic,
strategic, placemaking – is to proceed with Option 1 (full civic quarter
scheme, including value engineering). This secures the public benefits - civic
function, revenue potential and placemaking for coming generations. This does
not preclude any future council deciding to let out a greater or smaller
proportion of the commercial space of the Guildhall at any future time as an
operational or financial decision.
II. Option 3 remains a plausible option: to delay
a decision on the Guildhall for a few years, should members prefer to pass the
decision to a future unitary authority. This allows the potential for greater
certainty relating to space requirements post Local Government Reform. However,
it increases the risk of construction inflation and further deterioration of
the building condition making the project unaffordable, there would continue to
be spend on maintaining two buildings rather than one in the interim, and in
all likelihood further technical spend would be required on design updates and
a new planning submission (current permission expires in 2029). For that
reason, it is not the recommended option.
III. The s151 assessment of these recommendations
as set out below.
IV. The
progress of the Civic Quarter project with planning permission for the
Guildhall, Corn Exchange and the Market Square and public realm proposals; the
planning submission of the temporary market; the finalisation of financial
modelling, business plans, cost plans and value engineering work; and the
development of decant and HR plans.
V. That the decision about the Civic Quarter
project is for the Cabinet as the Council’s Executive to make. However, the
budget required to progress any of the four options would need to be approved
by Full Council.
1.2 The Cabinet unanimously
resolved to:
VI. Proceed
with the full Civic Quarter Project incorporating the identified value
engineering measures (option 1), as the preferred approach to securing the
future of the Guildhall, Corn Exchange, Market Square and associated public
realm.
VII. Delegate to the s151 Officer the design and
implementation of effective and frequent capital monitoring arrangements to
mitigate the risk of potential capital overspends as outlined in section
4.12-4.15 of the Officer’s report.
VIII. Delegate
authority to the s151 Officer and Director of Economy & Place for the sale
or lease of Mandela House, and potentially other assets identified through
review in conjunction with the relevant Cabinet Member
IX. Delegate authority to the Assistant Director
of Development in consultation with the Leader, Cabinet Member for Finance, Cabinet
Member for Inclusive Economy and Skills and Opposition Spokes for material
changes to technical design, procurement, decant planning, stakeholder
engagement and all associated preparations necessary for delivery of the
approved programme, noting an anticipated start on site in early 2027 and
subject to the approved total project budget.
X. Delegate authority to the Assistant Director
of Development and s151 Officer in consultation with Cabinet Member for Finance,
Cabinet Member for Inclusive Economy and Skills and Opposition Spokes to
enter into contracts with SRM subject to the approved total project budget.
1.3 The Cabinet unanimously resolved to note the S151
assessment of recommendations:
Financial modelling of all four options has been undertaken
by our external consultants and challenged and verified by the council’s
Finance team. The modelling shows that option 1 can be accommodated within the
council’s current approved Medium-Term Financial Strategy, but only by
allocating income from the Park Street redevelopment that would otherwise be
available to support the wider General Fund.
Furthermore, this assessment is based upon a number of
significant modelling assumptions. The key financial risks associated with the
project are: capital cost overruns; higher than
assumed interest rates at the point of initial borrowing or future refinancing;
lower than anticipated rental income from commercial space at the Guildhall;
and lower than anticipated income from the Corn Exchange. Should any or all of
these risks crystallise, the council may need to seek additional General Fund
savings in the future to cover any losses.
If option 1 is approved by Full Council, the following
mitigating actions are strongly recommended: -
XI. the
creation of a Civic Quarter revenue contingency reserve to cover early year
planned losses and provide a buffer against any changes in assumptions, as set
out at paragraph 5.4
XII. a bespoke
capital project monitoring process to reduce the risk of unplanned capital
overruns and allow early mitigating action to be taken, as set out at
paragraphs 4.12-4.15 of the Officer’s report.
1.4 Cabinet unanimously resolved to recommend to Council:
To approve new capital expenditure of £86.880 million to
deliver Option 1, to secure the long-term future of the Guildhall, Corn
Exchange, Market Square and associated public realm.
Council is recommended to delegate authority to the s151
Officer to carry out technical virements between capital and revenue budgets in
respect of costs which form part of the project but cannot be capitalised under
accounting regulations (for example support to market traders).
Publication date: 18/11/2026
Date of decision: 16/11/2026
Effective from: 24/11/2026
Current call-in Count: 0